Hardening Quantum Proof: A Tale of Two Solvers

Director of Operations, Quantum Rings

CTO, BlueQubit
Milestone 3 of Hardening Quantum Proof was broken by two independent solvers within hours of each other. Here's what happened, what was achieved, and what this means for Enigma.
In late June, qBitTensor Labs released the third milestone of Hardening Quantum Proof, a challenge focused on breaking peaked circuits in collaboration with BlueQubit.
For nearly three months, the milestone stood unbroken, and the prize for doing so climbed from $10,000 to $27,500.
Then all of a sudden, submissions skyrocketed and within days, the milestone was broken. Twice.
This breakthrough goes a long way in validating the thesis of the Enigma challenge network and has produced two valuable exploits for BlueQubit to design against as they seek to prove quantum advantage through peaked circuits.
Here's the story of what happened.
What Is Hardening Quantum Proof?
Quantum computing has a major trust problem.
Say a company tells you their machine just ran a calculation no classical computer could handle. How do you check? You can't just run it yourself; that's the whole point. It could be genuine quantum hardware. It could also be a classical simulator or noise delivered by broken hardware or a bad actor.
Peaked circuits are BlueQubit's proposed answer. A peaked circuit is a quantum program embedded with a hidden bitstring -- the kind of circuit that is trivial for a real quantum computer to execute but near impossible to simulate (in theory) on a classical computer. At Milestone 3's size, each circuit had up to 72 quadrillion possible outputs to search.
If this solutions holds, peaked circuits become a quantum proof: a quick, checkable test that a machine is really doing quantum computation.
If it doesn't hold, someone needs to find out before it becomes engrained in critical infrastructure.
That's the challenge. BlueQubit, one of the leading experts on peaked circuits, designs them. Enigma, qBitTensor Labs's challenge platform on the Bittensor network, pays anyone who can find the peak using only classical hardware.
Every break exposes a new exploit in the generation of these circuits, allowing BlueQubit to harden their design and release the next milestone. Every hold proves that the design is getting stronger. Either way, the field gets closer to a verdict on if this is a practical solution to the trust problem.
Why Milestone 3 Was Different
On their own, peaked circuits are fairly trivial to simulate classically. BlueQubit solves this by padding the middle of their peaked circuits with with obfuscation blocks. These blocks are composed of a random circuit followed by its inverse, creating a computationally expensive identity block. The structure of this identity block is obfuscated with a set of operations that sweep, mask, and swap qubits, making it difficult to detect.
In April, researchers at IBM published a method that exploits the structure of these obfuscation blocks. It works through the circuit from the middle outward so the padding's two halves cancel, and strips out the hidden qubit shuffles as it goes. IBM predicted that adding more obfuscation would make this attack more expensive, but wouldn't close the underlying gap. Earlier Enigma winners built on the same ideas to clear Milestones 1 and 2 within the challenge's first few weeks.
Milestone 3 put IBM's prediction to the test. Its circuits had 48–56 qubits and over 1,400 two-qubit gates, roughly twice the size of Milestone 1, with more obfuscation layered through them to hide the structure further.

How a peaked circuit is built. Adapted from Fig. 2 of Gharibyan et al., "Heuristic Quantum Advantage with Peaked Circuits," arXiv:2510.25838 (2025).
The Race To The Finish
For months, the milestone held strong against the barrage of submissions, with most barely scratching the surface of what was required to win.
This was the kind of milestone that BlueQubit described as one that "quantum experts would find challenging".
Then suddenly, submissions surged -- not one, but two competitors were racing to the finish, battling to be the first to claim the grand prize.
After two hard-fought days, one emerged victorious.
Just hours later, the second crossed the finish line as well.
The Payout
What was more remarkable than the fact that the milestone was solved by two participants within hours of each other was that their solutions took their own unique approaches to exploiting the mirror structure of the obfuscation blocks.
Enigma milestones are designed to be winner-take-all, so the first solver receives the full $27,500 prize.
But the second solution still has real value and reveals an attack vector that's just as important.
A second independent method is exactly what BlueQubit needs to harden the next design, and it serves as an entirely different piece of IP.
To make sure that this IP sees the light of day, a one-time $10,000 award was issued to the runner-up in exchange for open-sourcing their solution.
Two Approaches to the Same Weakness
Both solvers started from the published work of IBM and our previous milestones, but took it in their own direction.
The first solver took a surgical approach. They worked out that each of the extra obfuscation blocks, however complex it looks, amounts to little more than a reshuffling of the qubits. So they found each block, cut it out, replaced it with its reshuffle, and measured and put back the small leftover. That turned a Milestone 3 circuit back into a basic peaked circuit, which known methods solve quickly. They also found a faster way to run the cancellation itself, and required several independent calculation methods to agree before submitting.
The second solver took a search-based approach. They found the two main obfuscation modules by spotting gates that exactly undo each other. Then they ran the cancellation starting from one module and working towards the other, hunting for the point where the calculation collapsed into something small. From there, they rebuilt a much shorter circuit and solved that.

The two share no code, arriving at their solutions independently of one another. And as far as we can tell, neither technique appears in the published literature, meaning they've each discovered new attack vectors for BlueQubit to design against in Milestone 4.
"Putting our circuits in front of the world to solve classically is the most honest test we could ask for. Milestone 3 was the hardest construction we've put in front of Enigma, and it held for three months against some very formidable researchers. Watching it fall to two independent methods showed us exactly what we need to do to harden Milestone 4." — Hayk Tepanyan, CTO, BlueQubit
This is exactly how the open model is supposed to work. Published research and past winning solutions became the starting point, putting everyone on a level playing field. The winners then open-source their solutions, raising the bar for what's possible for everyone.
Why This Matters
For quantum computing: Milestone 3 is a real-world data point on an open research question. The added obfuscation made these circuits very difficult to crack, but they still ultimately fell to clever algorithms that could run in four hours on a single GPU without internet access.
This is exactly the kind of public evidence the field needs before trusting any test of quantum advantage.
For Enigma: This result shows the whole model working.
- The market set the price: The prize started at $10,000 and grew the longer the milestone went unsolved. At $27,500, it got solved.
- The prizes are attracting serious work: The prize pools are doing what they're meant to do: drawing in substantial, independent solutions to a problem a leading research group designed to be hard.
- The IP portfolio grew by two: Winning solutions are published under an open-source license that requires anyone building on them commercially to open-source their own work too unless they license the solution from qBitTensor Labs. There's already been signs of interest from a quantum company in the IP from this milestone.
- It compounds: Milestone 4 will build directly off these solutions, raising the bar for miners and challenging them to find completely new exploits.
What's Next
BlueQubit is preparing the Milestone 4 circuits now, informed by everything Milestone 3 taught us. It's coming soon.
If you're a quantum or tensor-network researcher who read this and thought "I'd have done it differently," good. Both solutions will be published. Read them, beat them, and get paid for it.
Come contribute to Enigma, the world's decentralized research lab and help break today to build a better tomorrow.