Back to News
BroadcastYouTube

qBitTensor Labs Live — November 12, 2026

November 12, 202656:53

RSA-560 falls to a solution about 2x better than the best public approach, with RSA-580 up next; Hardening Quantum Proof Milestone 4 is broken within two hours of going live, with circuits solved in about three minutes each, sending BlueQubit back to the drawing board; a Fortune 500 company is weighing a challenge of its own while the community votes on the next unpartnered Enigma challenge; SN48 and Open Quantum add Cirq, Qrisp, simulators (including the Quantum Rings simulator), a VS Code extension and the OQ Cal calibration standard; mining without owning a QPU opens up through trusted quantum providers; the team recaps Shizzy Unchained, the CU Qiskit Fall Fest and the Intermountain Quantum Competition at BYU; and Bob announces BeyondNISQ, a new podcast on the future of compute launching in December.

A slightly shorter episode than usual: the November 12th broadcast started 30 minutes early so Bob could make an industry advisory board meeting with Elevate Quantum. The team covers Enigma, SN48 and Open Quantum, recent events and community sentiment, and closes with a change to how they'll share updates after this episode: a new podcast, BeyondNISQ, aimed at an audience well beyond Bittensor.

Breaking RSA: 560 Falls, 580 Is Next

  • RSA-560 has been broken, and the new target is RSA-580. Bob admitted that if he'd thought anyone could break 560 in this compute environment, he would have made it the first milestone instead of 340. He had expected the challenge to stall much earlier.
  • The win came from combining work from Bittensor miners with breakthroughs from outside the ecosystem. The winner started from the new approaches behind the record 896-bit factorization. On their own, those weren't enough to break 560 in Enigma's environment, so the miner optimized them further for about a 2x improvement over the public solution.
  • ShorShot recalled the jump from 340 to 460, when people said the milestones were impossible, and pointed out that some of that pushback is people angling for easier prizes. Bob agreed that social manipulation is a real tactic.
  • 580 is a big stretch. The 530 and 560 breaks both followed major releases elsewhere in the industry. Without another step change, tuning alone has a long way to go, and Bob wouldn't be surprised if 580 stands for two or three months. His hope is that the next big breakthrough happens on Bittensor, not just gets picked up there. Some of the people working on these problems are very serious researchers.

Hardening Quantum Proof: Milestone 4 Falls in Two Hours

  • "A Tale of Two Solvers": after Milestone 3 fell, the team approached BlueQubit about writing up the story, and BlueQubit asked to co-author it. The article went out a couple of weeks ago on both teams' socials. Similar collaborations are being discussed with Terra Quantum.
  • Milestone 4 was solved within two hours of being published. The fastest milestones usually go in 12 to 24 hours, and some last months. The peaked circuits were solved in an average of about three minutes each, against a four-hour limit.
  • The recent solutions grew out of an IBM paper describing a weakness in the obfuscation: you could work in from both sides and strip it away. Bob added that BlueQubit had built resistance to that exact approach. The winning solution found the same symmetry could still be exploited, but only by looking much more carefully at what the circuits were actually doing.
  • Omar: this is a big result for both Enigma and BlueQubit. Finding a flaw like this before peaked circuits become a standard is exactly what the incentive model is for. Bob: had the industry built a narrative around "finally, something undeniably quantum-proof" and then had it break, it would have been another pie-in-the-face moment. Hats off to BlueQubit for putting their work out there to be attacked.
  • There's no date for Milestone 5. The break was serious enough that BlueQubit is going back to the drawing board. Bob hopes they'll fail fast with the next versions: form a hypothesis, make a harder circuit, ship it, and let the community show how well each technique holds up.

What's Next for Enigma: A Long Shot and a Community Vote

  • The long shot: the team is in talks with a Fortune 500 company. A fairly senior internal champion has pitched an Enigma challenge to several stakeholders. The company would design the challenge itself to create value for its own organization and industry, not just put its name on one the team built. Bob is sharing this much earlier than he normally would. It's still a moonshot, he puts it at roughly 50/50, and a big company with layers of VPs and a PR department won't move as fast as a quantum startup.
  • An unpartnered challenge in the meantime. The team has plenty of technical problems that would make strong Enigma challenges. The slow part is always finding and onboarding a partner. So the team will post five or more of its favorite challenge options on the qBitTensor Labs Discord on Friday, November 13. Each will include a description and a working prototype. Voting closes Monday, and the winners will be announced after that. The team reserves a veto, but Bob puts the odds of following the vote at 90%+.
  • One of the industry partners working with the team on the OQ Cal calibration standard (see below) would be a good fit for one of the options. If that one wins, the "unpartnered" challenge might end up with a partner after all.

SN48 + Open Quantum: New Frameworks

  • The team runs Quantum Rings, which built Open Quantum to be the open infrastructure layer between developers and quantum compute. SN48 is closely aligned with that work, and the ecosystem around it has been growing.
  • Cirq, Google's framework and the third most popular after PennyLane and Qiskit, is live in beta. A few users are already running it successfully, and it will likely become 1.0 soon.
  • Qrisp, from a European partner, launched around the Munich Quantum Software Summit, and the Qrisp team promoted the launch on its socials and at the conference. Qrisp aims a bit higher level, abstracting away low-level details so people can build circuits at a higher level, while still supporting the low-level work. It's backed largely by European organizations but is spreading. It came up at a US event Omar attended the day before.

Simulators on Open Quantum

  • Open Quantum now offers the community's most popular simulators, so users can run circuits with more qubits than today's quantum computers can handle. Open Quantum takes care of the different file formats, options and quirks of each simulator.
  • That includes the Quantum Rings simulator, available for the first time without a trial license. Bob's co-founder Venkat rebuilt it for the online version, and it is already carrying most of the simulator traffic. One BYU student ran about 14 hours of 120-qubit simulations (hundreds of jobs) over a weekend. Those circuits are far more complex than anything a real quantum computer can run today.
  • Simulators are free during the beta while the team makes sure everything works. They plug into the SDK, so you can bring Qiskit, PennyLane or any other framework, or submit QASM directly.
  • Traction: almost 100 new users a week, referral rates as high as 30% over the trailing 30 days, and far more returning users than a typical SaaS product.

VS Code Extension and OQ Cal

  • A new VS Code extension complements the SDK and MCP work. The team open-sourced a parser and syntax highlighter for checking circuit syntax in the editor. A validation step pre-compiles the code against the chosen QPU or simulator. Jobs can be submitted and tracked from VS Code. Results, there or on the web, show the original QASM, the processed format, a circuit diagram, the output and some basic statistics.
  • QPU calibration data is now available in beta. Because Open Quantum reaches QPUs through several providers (and sometimes directly), the team created an open, platform-agnostic standard for calibration data, OQ Cal, and published version 0.1 to get feedback from industry partners.
  • Bob: everyone in quantum knows QASM, which started as one company's open standard and became the de facto one. Nothing like that exists for calibration data, and anyone doing serious work on a quantum computer needs it. The goal is for "send me an OQ Cal" to become normal.

Mining Without Owning a QPU

  • Miners can now buy QPU time from trusted quantum providers instead of owning a QPU. Open Quantum is the first trusted provider. It signs the jobs it runs, and that certificate proves the circuit ran on a real quantum computer and counts for validation. Running simulators on your own GPUs and CPUs may come later.
  • Until now, the team had to do most of the mining itself. The only way to verify that someone had a quantum computer was an onerous manual check, which wasn't in the spirit of Bittensor. As community miners take on capacity, the team will wind down its own miners, though it will keep some running to keep the subnet healthy if community capacity drops.
  • The code and incentive mechanisms have been live for weeks and were smoke-tested in production. The only thing left was a server-side gate, which ShorShot planned to flip right after the stream and announce in chat.
  • The team is pushing other providers to offer trusted compute too. Bob also sees simulators and trusted providers coming together, using the decentralized compute miners have already invested in.

Events: Shizzy Unchained, Qiskit Fall Fest, Intermountain Quantum Competition

  • Shizzy Unchained: Bob was impressed by how professional the podcast was. It started on SN48's recent price appreciation and spent a lot of time on Enigma and on when quantum computers might break the elliptic-curve encryption that protects Bitcoin.
  • Qiskit Fall Fest (CU): IBM lets universities host Fall Fests, and the host finds its own funding. CU's drew over 100 registered participants, mostly students along with researchers and faculty. Bob was on the opening panel with people from NIST, Quantinuum, Icarus Quantum and Infleqtion. A few connections from the event could help with one of the potential Enigma challenges, and some students are eager to give input before it goes to the higher-ups.
  • ShorShot: from inside Bittensor, it's easy to think everyone knows it, but the bubble is still small. Bob saw the other side of that recently: someone he cold-emailed for a favor wrote back, "By the way, love what you're doing with Enigma."
  • Intermountain Quantum Competition (BYU): the first IQC. Quantum Rings ran its circuit runtime prediction challenge again, which supports pricing simulators properly on Open Quantum and SN48. That's part of why backends on Open Quantum are free today: it's in beta, and the team is still working out pricing. Omar gave an industry spotlight on Open Quantum and sat on a panel with representatives from IonQ and the head of quantum at Moderna. A lot of students signed up afterward. The public tier runs through Bittensor, so that brought new traffic through SN48. Enigma came up on the panel too, in the discussion of quantum hype, advantage and cybersecurity. Several strong hackathon competitors came up afterward to ask about it, and Omar hopes a few become miners.
  • On crypto: Omar sees business decision-makers worry about crypto's volatility, while the scientists who actually take on the challenges mostly don't mind. As Hayk from BlueQubit put it, if they're smart enough to take on these challenges, they're smart enough to set up a Bittensor wallet to claim their prize. Bob: decentralized innovation and big prizes excite people. The work is bringing them in slowly and comfortably.

Community Sentiment

  • Sentiment is mixed, tracking the price. SN63 got an uptick that has since been given back. There's real excitement for new challenges, especially AI and cybersecurity, and with Hardening Quantum Proof on pause while BlueQubit builds the next milestone, this is a good time to launch one.
  • Things feel slow. People want momentum. The challenges have been running their course, there haven't been many big announcements, and comms have been quieter. JB summed it up: the team has plenty of ammo in the chamber and is being careful about firing it, but it's time. Omar: Bittensor moves fast, and much of the price action comes from new and exciting things.
  • Bob: "Slow is smooth and smooth is fast," though he admits he's usually the one pushing to go faster. Enigma is doing exactly what it should (if 580 feels hard, "innovate harder"), but smooth operation isn't what the Bittensor community wants to see. Launching a challenge also takes more than it looks: choosing the problem, setting milestones, marketing, finding partners, hardening it against miners' early exploits, and picking each next milestone from the last solution.
  • If the big partner comes through, it would show that working with Bittensor is OK for large companies and could open the way for other high-profile partners. The team is in similar early talks with other potential major collaborators. The likely path: a challenge or two with small partners or none, then a big launch with a big partner. If that happens, Bob wouldn't be surprised to see SN63 among the top subnets.

Next Up: The BeyondNISQ Podcast

  • Const's Exploit keynote: just before announcing gamma, Const hinted that the next incentive mechanism may focus on bringing outside capital and outside innovators into Bittensor, not just moving attention between subnets. Bob suggested going back and listening to that part. Gamma, which measures dollars spent on subnet services, fits the same direction. It's also one of the reasons the planned buybacks haven't started: if the next incentive mechanism rewards spending through gamma, buying and burning now could use up that capital before the change.
  • The podcast: Bob is handing over his BeyondNISQ brand (he'll likely switch to something like NISQ) to a podcast on the future of compute. The QR code on the slide leads to a YouTube placeholder. A teaser should drop in the first or second week of December, with episodes starting in early December.
  • Instead of putting prep time into an update for a few hundred people already in Bittensor, the team will aim it at a much bigger audience, with regular touch points that can bring outside innovators and outside dollars in. That comes at the cost of qBitTensor Labs Live in its current form. Bittensor-specific updates will move to a more time-efficient format, likely with more live Q&A.
  • What to expect: the same three hosts; regular interviews (building on good feedback to the Taylor Hartley segment); recurring guests from outside the core team; and topics beyond the subnets and quantum, including data centers in space, full self-driving and megafabs, which ShorShot is passionate about. Most quantum and tech podcasts are polished and dry. This one aims to be more informal and to say the things people usually won't say on podcasts.
  • How to help: subscribe on YouTube now so the channel starts with some momentum. Episodes will also be posted on X.
  • Bob's wrap-up: SN63 has been in a tough spot since it got "Arbos'd," but it seems to have found its real baseline. From here: "Let's just start growing and doing good stuff."