Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [00:05]Hey everybody and welcome to qBitTensor Labs Live. Today is November 12th, and we're excited to have you with us again. sorry for the weird start time. We're like 30 minutes earlier than we usually have done these. I have a hard stop at the bottom of the hour for an industry advisory board meeting with Elevate Quantum. And I, you know, that wasn't the type of meeting you can get to reschedule. so the other side effect of that, I suppose, is that we're not gonna go more than an hour. In fact,
Ideally we'll go a little bit less than an hour so I can drop off and make a coffee before joining that. But okay, thanks everybody for joining us. as always, these are ideas that we're gonna be talking about, not promises. we'll give you a lot of opinions, but we do not provide any investment or legal advice. you guys have been doing a great job of using this content for good and not for evil, and as long as you keep doing that, we can keep putting out opinions.
And if you're still here, then you agree to all that and we're gonna roll. So today, you know, at this point, I mean, don't know, I feel like probably for the last six months or so, this agenda has just been like almost exactly the same every time. So no new surprises here. We're gonna talk about subnet 63 Enigma. we're gonna talk about subnet 48 quantum. And then you know, we'll go through some of the recent events that we've been doing.
we'll go through general community sentiment. And then we do have a special section, which is we're gonna make a little adjustment in how we're broadcasting information out after this qBitTensor Labs Live. So we'll talk about what is up next after that. Cool. So without further ado, let's jump into Enigma. I guess the first big news on Enigma is breaking RSA. we've continued to see just like innovation. I mean, we keep kind of being a little bit surprised.
At at how much innovation we're seeing? I mean, so fast. So like if I will say if I thought people could just break 560 with this compute environment, I would have made that milestone one. Like we made milestone one. Okay. Milestone one being 340, that was a low bar. I'm gonna own that. But getting into 460, 480, 500, 512, like I sort of thought this challenge was gonna get like jammed up significantly earlier.
But the combination of innovation from the miners in the Bittensor ecosystem, combined with innovations from outside the Bittensor ecosystem, have really enabled a lot of movement on this. And so we've seen that as soon as somebody in the industry finds any kind of breakthrough, the Bittensor community, they're like massive resource investigators. They find it, they apply it to the problem. most of the time, they're needing to continue and improve on those. and so like
we're now at the point where 560 has been broken and the the new challenge is 580 But in order to achieve 560, the winning solution for that basically took some of the new approaches that had been released on this like 896-bit thing that we're talking about. And they started by trying to apply those. But those solutions on their own actually weren't like sufficient to break 560 in the compute environment. And so they essentially had to like
further optimized to get about a 2x further improvement on the solution that was public, which means that, you know, the $400,000 in supercompute time that they put on like the 896-bit solution essentially could be cut in half if the solution that came out of this were applied to that. Which, you know, essentially means that you know, you could take that $400,000 bill that you get for running on a bunch of GPUs.
And potentially cut that down to 200 if you wanted to replicate that experiment. And so yeah, really super cool stuff. Now I will say I think 580 is it's a big stretch from 560. I always feel this way every time we put a challenge out, but it will not surprise me. It like I see ShorShot's face already, and I can't wait for you I can't wait for your input on this. But it would not surprise me if this one stood for like
two or three months before being broken.
Ryan (ShorShot) [04:26]I yeah, I mean I was I was just thinking back at the the time when I think we jumped from three forty to four sixty and everyone was complaining it's impossible. I bet I mean, you know, there's probably some manipulation going on there as well, right? Like people want people want easier stuff because then they get money, right? So yeah.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [04:32]Manipulation like people trying to socially manipulate. Yeah, you know. I mean, I I I will totally own that like social manipulation is a vector that people are taking. Yeah. Now, okay, so that said though.
Ryan (ShorShot) [04:52]Yeah, but I I t totally 580 is is pretty difficult here, so
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [05:02]if we look at the 530 breakthrough and we look at the 560 breakthrough, both of those did align with something, some major step function being released out in the industry. And the amount of improvement that like if there's not a new breakthrough, the amount of like tuning and improving that's gonna have to happen to go from like 560 to 580 is pretty massive. Right. And so like I'll I mean, I'm I hope, like my hope.
would be that instead of taking a breakthrough from outside of Bittensor and applying it to the problem here, that we actually start to see not just tuning, not just improving things to work on GPUs better, but the next major breakthrough happening on Bittensor. And I think that's what we're gonna need to see in 580. Either we're gonna see it outside and someone's gonna pick up on it immediately and they're watching things and they apply it, or we're gonna see that breakthrough come from one of our miners. And we've got some big brains working on this stuff. I don't know if people really like
you know, have have I don't know how doxxed or undoxxed people are publicly who are working on this, but we've got some pretty big brains on this stuff, which is cool. All right. So I spent w I mean I just said I was gonna move fast and then we spent like ten minutes talking about one slide, so I better pick it up a little bit. In fact, Omar, do me a solid and you cover the hardening quantum proof faster than I would. I don't I don't set a high bar.
Ryan (ShorShot) [06:15]One slide, yeah.
Omar [06:24]We'll try our best. so there's a fair enough. There's been a lot going on with hardening quantum proof since the last live stream, which I guess has been a little bit ago, but the last time we were live, we talked about HQP 3 being broken. And you know, we had sort of alluded to BlueQubit being very excited about this. And it was to the point where we approached them saying, Hey, we want to write an article on this, detailing, you know, the story because it
happened in a peculiar way and highlighting the significance and they got really excited and jumped on it and said, we should co-author this. So the Hardening Quantum Proof, you know, a Tale of Two Solvers article went out a couple of weeks ago that was broadcast on BlueQubit's socials as well as our own. And the hope is that, you know, their enthusiasm then translates to, you know, more outside interest. so I think a lot of you have seen this article, but we wanted to draw attention to it of like
You know, our sponsors are getting you know, invested and and involved and yeah, we've been talking with Terra Quantum about doing some similar stuff and so we'll see where in the pipeline that ends up coming.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [07:36]Cool man, yeah, that's awesome. And and with this, I suppose that also, you know, comes with the big announcement that HQP 4 was broken. Talk us through that and like I mean some of the implications of how crazy the solution really was.
Omar [07:52]Yeah. So we have the stats up here that I think are particularly the most interesting thing about this achievement is most of our quickest milestones go down within twenty-four hours of being posted. some of them will be months, but if we have one that goes within twelve or twenty-four hours, we say, Wow, that went really quickly. This milestone was solved within two hours of it being published, which is insane. and the rate at which each of the peaked circuits were solved,
They averaged three minutes of runtime, which is, you know, far below our four-hour threshold. So the the magnitude of this solution is pretty nuts. And a lot of this comes, it it builds off of both of the solutions actually from HQP3 and sort of perfects it. all of the solving methods used for the last few milestones were based off of this IBM paper that said, hey, you know, here's this, I guess, hole in the obfuscation, and here's how you'd exploit it. And the last two solutions really put that into practice. And, you know, we can see.
These level four peaked circuits are effectively trivialized with this method. And so that is a huge breakthrough for both Enigma and BlueQubit is we now have a really great idea of what doesn't work. And that is insanely important to know before you know publishing this as a standard and saying, you know, hey, we're gonna rely on peaked circuits. If a glaring flaw like this exists, it's great that we found it. So this is you know super exciting for us and sort of validates.
the incentive model that you know Enigma is built on.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [09:25]Yeah, well and man, I I gotta say, I don't know that I would say that this is just the perfection of the IBM paper. I think that so okay. Yeah, not to like nitpick or anything like that, but the IBM paper sort of had like this assumption that like you could you know at a really high level not getting nerdy, you could kind of like work from both sides and like rip off the obfuscation. And BlueQubit actually had this really cool innovation, which I didn't like it was a black box to me, so I actually didn't know how they were obfuscated.
obfuscating, but they made it such that that didn't work anymore. You couldn't do that. And so there was like I think a lot of like speculation about how it how it had worked. And essentially the solution that was submitted here found that they had basically like built resistance to that, but that they could still exploit the same, you know, symmetry. it just it just sort of like required like a a much smarter approach of like inspecting what was actually happening and how to apply it.
And so, I think that this has had the effect of like seriously saving us from potential problems. Or like we we thought we had a solution that was really good, we being the industry, not quant, you know, not qBitTensor Labs But you know, essentially we thought we had a solution that was really good. And with smart enough people working on it for long enough, they broke it. And so had we like started to build a big narrative in the industry about like finally something that is completely undeniably quantum proof, and then it turned
out not to be. That would have been another pie in our face moment. So hats off to the BlueQubit team for putting I guess putting our money where their mouth is, But you know but like putting it out there and like it's hard. I mean it's hard to do that. In fact, like right now you know we're we're anticipating hardening quantum five but we don't know when that's gonna be because this, you know, basically like was so
impactful on the obfuscation approach that they were using, that they're essentially needing to go back to the drawing board. And I just hope that, you know, they're sort of open to failing fast with like the next ones. Like let's just let's make a hypothesis, make a harder one, let's ship it. Like let's not let perfect get in the way of good enough. you know, because I think we could get, you know, get some things out there and use the community to actually like understand how good these different techniques are.
Cool. All right, awesome. I'm I just I torpedoed you. I asked you to move fast and then I like torpedoed you. So so what we're working on now. I know, I'm bad. Okay. All right. I'll I swear I'm gonna move faster. All right. So what's next? The long shot. Okay. Why have we not put a new challenge out for Enigma yet? we are working on a long shot here. We are
Ryan (ShorShot) [11:59]That might have been longer than the first slide there, so
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [12:20]Currently engaging with a Fortune 500 company, a big name company. We have support from an internal champion at that company who's relatively high up and has actually pitched the idea of an Enigma challenge to multiple stakeholders at the company. this challenge would be like, you know, it's not just some like challenge that we built and then they slap their name on it. This is a challenge that they are actually designing to add value specifically to their organization and to their industry.
And I just want to say, I'm saying that we're working on this way earlier than I would normally say we're working on something, because this is in no way guaranteed. In fact, if anything, I would still put this in the category of a moonshot. but somehow this moonshot is about fifty fifty that such a big name company would be, you know, seriously considering working with the Bittensor ecosystem. you know, which is like, I mean it's
If if we can pull this off, it's beyond what I would have expected us to be able to pull off. so we're putting a lot of eggs in that basket. We're gonna see if we can make that work. it will take time, right? So working with a big company with, you know, layers of VPs and, you know, PR departments and stuff like that is not gonna move as fast as like working with a small quantum startup. But you know, if this pays off, it's it will be, you know, worth the wait. And so
FYI that is in the mix. Also, we can't really afford to just hang tight. And so I talked to the team and we essentially have decided we are gonna move forward with an additional challenge, with what we're calling an unpartnered challenge. And so the idea is that we actually are sitting on top of like a trove of different opportunities here. like there are so many problems, so many technical problems that fit well into Enigma challenges that
produce very important solutions. but the long pull in the tent is finding an industry partner to work with, you know, getting them on board, having their fingerprints on the implementation, et cetera, et cetera. And so we are we have decided that we're gonna go forward with an unpartnered solution. And what we're gonna do actually do is a really, I think, interesting experiment. We'll see how it works and we'll decide if we're gonna do it again. But we are going to post tomorrow on Discord our five top
Favorite options for the next challenge. All of these challenges actually will have like not only like the details of what the challenge is, but a prototype implementation already ready. So we're gonna open up voting for from y'all on these challenges. We're gonna close the voting on Monday. We'll sort of announce the winners. Now, okay, like if if it turns out that like one is a rock star in the community votes on a really dumb one or something like that, maybe we reserve the right to like veto.
But I would say ninety plus percent chance we're gonna listen to the outcome of these votes and launch the solution that that you guys propose. So yeah, we'll see where that goes. We're gonna do that on the qBitTensor Labs Discord. So if you're not a part of that, go join that. and it should be up tomorrow for voting. That's what we're doing with Enigma. did I miss anything, Omar, Ryan? Cool.
Omar [15:47]Think that covers most of it. A lot of exciting stuff in the pipeline.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [15:51]Nice. All right. Moving on to 48. So 48, I mean, just like full like full transparency. we all run a startup called Quantum Rings. and we launched Open Quantum, this platform, you know, essentially is aiming to be the open infrastructure layer that sits between all the developers and all the different quantum compute resources. And 48 quantum compute is just like super aligned with what we're doing, you know.
With what we're doing the rest of the time. And so we've actually seen like just a lot of progress on 48 and on the surrounding ecosystem around 48. And so we've been kind of you know excited to see that the community has been responding to that. for Ryan's benefit, because I think you're probably the guy talking about a lot of these slides, I rearranged these a little bit. so I'll give kind of a quick shout-out and then I'll maybe plug you to to talk to a few things here.
but the first thing is we did launch two new frameworks. So Cirq is like the third most popular quantum development framework after PennyLane and Qiskit That's Google's framework. we launched that. We did launch it in beta. We've seen a few use users come on and start using it successfully, and so we're likely to pull that out of beta and just call that 1.0 really soon. We also partnered with an organization that's
putting together a framework called Qrisp in Europe. we launched this around the Munich Quantum Software Summit. And you know, the European market I guess, Omar, would you say that Qrisp is primarily a European quantum development framework? I mean it sounds like weird to say. Like why would a region play into it?
Omar [17:33]Yeah, no, I I mean it's I think supported by a lot of the European organizations and it was designed to be sort of this, you know, European framework. But I we are seeing it sort of permeate outside of Europe. It was actually brought up at an event I was at yesterday, in the US. So it is gaining popularity worldwide, which is cool.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [17:51]Cool. Yeah. And so Qrisp, Qrisp is another framework. It is aiming to go a little bit higher level. they support the really low level stuff too, but it's aiming to abstract away some of those things and give people more ways to build quantum circuits at a little bit of a higher level.
and so yeah, we're really excited to have that. We were excited to have that team promoting it on their socials and promoting it at the conference. And so yeah, great great framework. and then ShorShot I'm gonna have you talk to this one, man. Talk talk us through simulators on open quantum.
Ryan (ShorShot) [18:25]Yeah, so we launched simulators you know that allows users to run quantum circuits that are higher qubits than possible by a quantum computer currently. so what we did is try to release the whole set of what's popular in the community.
as well as the quantum rings simulator as well. It's the first time it's been you've been able to just really other than like a trial license, be able to get on there and and run it super easily. And and you know the whole open quantum framework allows this to happen and provides us the compatibility between the different file formats and the different nuances of each simulator. Each simulator, you know, works differently and has different options on how it tries to
to process the circuit. so th we have a lot of divers diversity in between the the QPUs that we offer now and the simulators that we offer. So really nice.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [19:26]Yeah, and you know, one of the other things that I guess we don't say too much on on these slides, but quantum rings is actually like best known for our simulation. And my co-founder Venkat, who I feel like somebody said somebody called him like laser eyes or something like that, which is really funny. So he put his laser eyes on the simulator. Like the guy, it's it's a it's a hilarious metaphor, both because like he always does look very serious in his photos, but also because like once he like fixates on something, like he just disappears.
it's tunnel vision, he's disappeared to the rest of the world until he does the best possible job at that one thing. And so the online version of the quantum rings simulator is like epically better than our prior prior version, but like our prior version was epically better than any other simulator on the market. And so I mean, like you yeah, you can go run on IBM simulator or Google simulator or Xanadu's simulator, but like
All of the traffic so far has been running on the quantum ring simulator, really. Like, I mean, it's basically dominating the simulator traffic today. And I I like I saw a kid from BYU run like 14 hours of 120 qubit simulations, like hundreds of jobs over the weekend where it's like, you can't even do that on a real quantum computer. Like the circuits you're putting through are like way more complicated than you can do on a real quantum computer. And like
The guy's just running it for free right now on open quantum, which is nuts. so super excited about it. we did have a second slide on this, but actually I feel like you pretty much covered all of it already, ShorShot
Ryan (ShorShot) [21:09]Yeah, temporarily available in beta now for free for the simulators as we're kicking the tires and making sure things are working right. yeah, I mean this is a great and it just plugs into like all of our SDK work as well. So you know, it could bring any framework that you're gonna wanna run on, Qiskit, PennyLane, whatever, submit
QASM directly, it just works.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [21:36]Yeah. Pr pretty pretty amazing stuff. And so yeah, this whole idea that open quantum and SN 48 become like the open infrastructure layer where you can have any frameworks talking to any backends is looking like more and more just the way it is right now, right? so
We are we are seeing that we're attracting like almost a hundred new users a week in. We're seeing really high referral rates, like as much as like thirty percent in the last trailing thirty days. you know, we're seeing huge number of returning users, like much higher than your average SaaS offering. And so like things are feeling good. Things are feeling like the vision is sort of coming to fruition there. and some of the cool things that we don't talk about, because it's not like developer frameworks and it's not
Quantum computers are th like these other things on the periphery. So ShorShot, talk us through what this one is.
Ryan (ShorShot) [22:29]Yeah, so we decided to add a VS Code extension. really complements our SDK and other MCP work as well. And this just allows you to really just run circuits right from VS Code. We actually open sourced a parser and a syntax highlighter so you could open an editor in VS Code and see that your syntax for your circuit is right and that you could also
It's also compilable against a certain qu QPU or simulator because we go through a validation step which does a pre-compilation of the code. And then you're able to execute it right from VS Code, see the watch the status, and then we have a lot of enhancements when it came comes to the results of the job, and including online as well, if you're doing it through the web, where you could actually see the original QASM that you posted, a processed format.
most of the time that's QASM in these systems, other systems can do different formats depending on what they need to process. And then be able to see a circuit diagram along with that and then the results that are output and and do some basic statistical analysis on that. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [23:42]Totally, man. We should have done like a live demo instead of like all that stuff you just said. It's like it's such eye candy too. It looks so good. Like this these screenshots don't do it justice. Maybe if we finish early, which I like the chances of that seem slim. Maybe I'll maybe I'll have you live demo some of that stuff. Should we see? Let's see. Is this what you're gonna talk about?
Ryan (ShorShot) [23:47]Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. And i and then I don't know that we talk about it specifically in any other slide, so I just want to bring it up. Well, maybe the next slide. We'll let that roll over to the next slide and then let's yeah. So the on that VS Code plugin or on the web, we now have a beta feature for access to the calibration data of the QPUs themselves. And in order for us to kind of do that,
Ryan (ShorShot) [24:23]Because we use different providers on accessing these QPUs, sometimes we have direct access as well. being able to come up with a industry open source sta platform agnostic standard for calibration data. so we came up with OQ Cal and then published a first initial version to the internet 0.1. that way we could get some feedback from industry partners and be able to s to kind of like hope you know that we could get adoption onto this format.
yeah.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [24:56]Totally. Yeah. And and you know, not that I would let it slow us down, but one of the industry partners that we're collaborating with on this open qu calibration standard would actually be a pretty good fit for one of the challenges that we'll post up for Enigma. So if that one ends up winning, we'll see if we can kind of make stars align and pull a rabbit out of the hat and you know, actually launch the sponsorless one with a sponsor, but you know.
Yeah, it's this this is really cool. So everybody in the everybody in quantum talks about QASM, right? the quantum basically a quantum assembly. And that has become the de facto standard. People just they all pronounce it the same way, right? But it was just an open standard that a company put out. This
There is no standard for this right now. This is desperately needed for anybody that wants to do anything like serious on a quantum computer. And so yeah, super stoked to see if we can get this standard going. it'll be so cool if people are just like, send me an OQ Cal Maybe we could call it OQal. OQal, like the Q and the C, you know. We'll have to figure out the pronunciation. But yeah, super cool stuff. All right. you want to talk about this one too?
Ryan (ShorShot) [26:11]Yep.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [26:12]Yeah, keep it going, man. You got the floor.
Ryan (ShorShot) [26:15]Yeah, so we're gonna open up mining without owning a QPU and you know what you do is you purchase QPU time from trusted providers. we're open quantum is the first trusted provider with this ecosystem where we're gonna be able to sign jobs coming out of open quantum, use that certificate as a proof of trust that this provider was able to actually
you know, run the the circuit on a real quantum computer and then be able to use that as proof for a validation as as well in order to to start this public mining journey. There's a lot more to come I think of the future when it comes to running simulators on your own GPUs and stuff like that and and own CPUs. But this is this is the first step moving towards that and
opening it up for the the public to participate in this.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [27:16]Yeah, and but and by the way, the aim on this, so you know, up until up until this feature turning on, which I guess essentially happened right now, you know, the only option was for this. Need to push
Ryan (ShorShot) [27:30]I I might need to make an announcement after this af after the chat to push some buttons to to to kinda fully enable it here. So look out on the chat for when it'll actually be turned on here. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [27:43]But yeah, so so prior to this, like we essentially had to mine ourselves because like there was no way to n to be able to like verify that somebody actually had a quantum computer. We had a process, but like it was onerous and nobody would use that process, like which involved like us actually going and making sure you actually had a quantum computer.
and and like that really is not in the spirit of Bittensor. And so this change, you know, this cool trusted quantum provider concept with these signed packets allows for anybody to then spin up a miner. the aim will be that as an active miner community starts spinning up, we should aim to start spinning down. So like once we see that the capacity can be taken up by other miners, you know, all the miners that we had
have been running, you know, we'll sort of start to like wind those down over time. we will always need to keep some miners active, you know, in the event that like the community stops servicing the requests, we still need to make sure that the subnet stays healthy. but you know we'll we'll work to, you know, turn the knob down on ours as everybody else is turning the knob up on theirs.
So yeah, this is this is super exciting. And the code has been live for this for some time. I think this went out, I mean, it went out a number of weeks ago. We saw some good price appreciation right around the time that the code change went out. And so, like what it means to be a miner, like all the incentive mechanisms have been live, stuff like that. The only thing that stopped it from actually being live live is a gate on the server side, which we are flipping. And that essentially was just done so that we could test the code.
you know, in production before, you know. Yeah. That's awesome, man. I'm so stoked. I like that like it's so cool. Yeah, so cool. and then, you know, I think obviously like we don't put it on here, but we were talking about simulators on open quantum. And here we're talking about trusted quantum providers, but like obviously like those two worlds smashing together.
Ryan (ShorShot) [29:27]Yeah, give it a good smoke test for, you know, the past couple of weeks and it's it's did some bug squashing and I think we're we're good to go.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [29:53]really plays into the strengths of Bittensor too, which is to say how do we actually leverage the decentralized compute resources that miners have made the investment in, you know, could
Ryan (ShorShot) [30:03]Yeah. And we're gonna try to push with some other providers to get them to to provide trusted compute as well.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [30:18]Yeah. Awesome. Cool. Well, nice work, man. That is super cool. And yeah, so that's subnet 48. I was wrong. We're gonna end on time, man. We're doing it. We're do we're doing all right. All right. events. Omar, are you taking us through the events today? right. so first off, I wanna call I wanna call attention to the attention to the most important part about this, which is like ShorShot was was like
Ryan (ShorShot) [30:27]Ha ha ha.
Omar [30:33]Think you're taking us through your events.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [30:47]reminiscing about how like, you know, i if your friend if your friend made like a cassette tape of some audio and then gave it to you and you wanted to like duplicate it, you'd get this like slight, like just slightly shittier copy of the same audio. And if somebody duplicated yours, they'd get a slightly worse copy of your audio, like back in the olden days, right? So my face, man, like
Everybody I think what happened is I had a headshot at one point. Somebody used it and they're like, AI, make Bob in my picture. And then, you know, I got a slightly warped version of me. And then I think people grabbed the other one on the internet and they're like, AI, have Bob be in my picture. So now at this point, man, I don't even know if that looks like me anymore. Like like a check out but I do th I do feel like the cool like blotchy chest hair is kind of like nice though. You know, maybe I should maybe I should V neck and work on my chest hair.
But all right, back to the regularly scheduled program. okay. Shizzy Unchained. Good show, man. yeah, I thought Shizzy puts on a professional podcast. I I I was impressed with just a lot of the tech, his, you know, his ability to have like you know, intros with music while it's live, seamlessly cut into things. You know, I mean I was actually like, it's a lot of work. I thought that was really quite impressive. we went into it.
largely talking about subnet 48, 'cause we had just had price appreciation on that and I think Shizzy's podcast is really focused on price appreciation and speculation. but he also, you know, had a lot of interest in 63, so we ended up spending a lot of time talking about, you know, Enigma and when quantum computers will break you know, the elliptic curve encryption that protects Bitcoin and stuff like that. if you haven't seen it, you should check it out. It was it was kind of good. I I had a good time with it. And you know
It's also fun, I don't know. it's fun talking to scientists. It's also fun talking to people that have, no idea what a quantum computer is, too. we also did Fall Fest so there there's this cool thing. I'm gonna say some honest things about it, but like this cool thing called the Qiskit Fall Fest So basically it's this like program that IBM puts on where they let
Anybody from any university apply to host a fall fest. And then they have to, you know, present their case to IBM, what they're gonna do, why it's gonna be great. IBM blesses them to do a fall fest. They don't pay for it. They just, you know, give them permission to do it and to use the logo and the name and stuff like that. And then the organization works with their local institution, finds funding for, you know, all the things that they need to do, and they put on a fall fest. These are usually kind of like hackathons and also a bunch of like
learning activities and panels and stuff like that. Anyway, CU did one of these. they put it on. It was really a great thing that over a hundred participants register, you know, mostly students, but also researchers and faculties. And one of the really fun things to kick off the the Fall Fest was a panel discussion, which I was able to join. we had people from NIST, Quantinuum, Icarus Quantum, Infleqtion, you know, and and others.
there and so yeah it was really a lot of fun to be able to sort of be up on stage with really like a lot of geeks who know a ton of things that I don't know, but then also to be like, you know, the person who actually understands how end users are using this stuff today. which was a lot of fun. yeah, so with that though, we did make a couple connections that also
Are potentially helpful to one of the Enigma challenges. That's one of the funniest things is when you're talking to people about like quantum computers and then all of a sudden like an opportunity comes up to just like talk Enigma and you sort of like feel out like, will this go well if I go this way? So yeah, I've got a couple college college students who are like really eager to provide input on one of the potential challenges that we're talking about launching before sort of bringing it up to the higher levels to
to review it. See, I actually think to be honest, I feel like the exact opposite is always like funny. When you're like like so there was
Ryan (ShorShot) [34:53]It's kinda interesting, being involved with Bittensor, you think everyone you start to th feel like everyone knows about Bittensor and what it does, but then it's like th this bubble is still quite small and there's a lot of growth in Bittensor itself to be able to have it be a common name mm at the dinner table. So or at the conference room table. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [35:21]Legitimately one thing recently where like I had to do kind of like a cold reach out to somebody in quantum to ask a favor because like I don't even want to get into it. But it's like, you know, it's like very old school, like good old boys club. Like you need to have somebody to vouch for you for like a bunch of different things. And I needed somebody to vouch for me. So I'm cold reaching out to a bunch of different people. And eventually this one guy responds and he's like, By the way, love what you're doing with Enigma and I was like, what?
Like how did that how did that get in there? You know what I mean? Yeah. so yeah, so every once in a while, you know, you get that surprise in the other direction. So hit us up on the IM what was it? The IMQC, the IQC? Yeah.
Ryan (ShorShot) [35:52]That's hilarious. Yeah, yeah.
Yep. Yep.
Omar [36:06]IQC, yeah, so Intermountain Quantum Competition. yeah, I mean the fall is I guess fall and winter is usually a big time for us as quantum rings to make our tour of the quantum hackathon circuit. so most recently we were at this the first installation of the IQC at BYU. we were running we we've mentioned this challenge a couple times, but we're more or less trying to predict the runtime of circuits without actually executing them.
And all of that is in the name of adding simulators to 48 and Open Quantum and actually being able to price appropriately. If you look at Forty or if you look at, the back ends available on Open Quantum today, you'll notice they're all for free. And part of that is because, it's in beta and we want to encourage people to try it out. And part of that is because we're still working out how exactly we wanna price this. And so getting feedback from students and and having them work on it is an interesting way to get some new ideas that we may have
maybe haven't considered. I think the couple of most exciting things is we had a like industry spotlight where I spent most of my time talking about open quantum, and then an industry panel where I also spent a lot of time talking about open quantum, but I was also featured alongside representatives from IonQ. And then we had the head of quantum at Moderna on the panel. So there were some big names there, which was pretty exciting. And the the big takeaway I think is
I had so many students come up to me after the fact and say, Hey, I love what you're doing with open quantum. This is incredible. And so, we had tons and tons of signups on that and tons of people trying out the platform. And when people try out the platform, it's all routed through our this public tier, which is all routed through Bittensor. And so by extension, we've seen a bunch of new traffic sort of through Subnet 48, which is very exciting to see. I will say, and I don't think I told you guys about this, but Enigma did come up during the panel.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [38:01]no way.
Omar [38:02]we were we were talking, I think, about the the topic of quantum hype and sort of finding new instances of quantum advantage and that and then actually also cybersecurity. So both the breaking RSA and hardening quantum proof challenges got mentioned, and I said, Hey, come talk to me, you know, about this afterwards if you want to hear more. You know, this touches a lot on, you know, many of the pressing issues in the quantum industry. And we had a lot of students, some that are
you know, very successful hackathon participants come up and say, Hey, you know, what is Enigma? And I would walk them through it and say you can learn earn a bunch of money. And so the hope is that they'll you know, stay on board and maybe try their hand because they are, you know, these very talented individuals. And if we can bring more talent into the fold, you know, that looks great for us. So I'm you know, hoping we have a a couple of new miners that that might be coming to us soon. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [38:58]Yeah, that's well that's that's cool. Yeah, but and and like it makes me happy that you're like comfortable with Enigma coming up and able to just jump into it because yeah, I mean like that it it's it is very weird, but like like while people are a little bit like skeezy about the like cryptocurrency part of it, like or at least they kinda present I think pro like
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [39:21]science people, very like high professional people like present that way, even though they may not totally feel that way. Like behind the scenes, you they might actually trade crypto behind the scenes.
they sort of like present that. But like when it comes to like the idea of decentralized innovation, decentralized state-of-the-art technology development, you know, earning prizes, even if those prizes are in crypto for v for very cool contributions, like all of those things are exciting to people. Like the entire thing is really exciting to people. It's just like how do you sort of like bring them in a little slowly and comfortably and into that journey?
Omar [39:58]Yeah, I think also sort of on that topic is what I'm noticing is a lot of the sort of business or decision makers who, you know, have this risk to take on are very concerned about crypto because it is so volatile. But a lot of the scientists, the people that are actually, you know, participating in the challenges, are usually all for it. And I think we were talking to Hayk from BlueQubit a while ago, and he was like, Yeah, you know, if these guys are smart enough to take on these challenges, they're certainly smart enough to spin up a Bittensor wallet to claim their prize.
and and I think what we're seeing is, you know, more and more of these people that are actually participating are like, I you know, I don't care if it's crypto, I I just wanna participate. And that's awesome. You know, we're building out this talent network. But, you know, as we've touched on, then convincing these companies to, you know, put their name on what we're doing is a bit of an uphill battle. But, you know, it's one we seem to be doing quite well at. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [40:27]Because
Well you know so real quick we'll we'll move on in just a second here, but like those top two photos in the top right there, are those both real photos? Like totally. That's exactly what I'm asking.
Omar [40:59]they were not AI generated if that's what you're asking. They're just very professional there was a professional photographer on site. I will say the very top left one was staged. but they are they are, you know, completely authentic they're they're real photos.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [41:16]Now the bot the bottom left one, that feels more like somebody grabbed their camera and then did this and then photoshopped quantum rings onto a banner or something like that. But like the top two look like straight off of like a high-end marketing website. Yeah. Are like those kids are like real kids doing the hackathon?
Omar [41:24]Ha ha.
Mm-hmm.
Those are real kids, the the top left team, those were the runners up for our challenge. And then the middle kids were not part of our challenge, but they did use open quantum in their solution. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [41:36]Nice. sweet. Yeah. Yeah, that's cool. Well, actually, a good cool investment from from the university to have a high-end photographer that's like, yeah, smart. And you know, so one of the themes, you know, one of the themes that you had put out there, and I guess it's kind of actually been a theme throughout the presentation today, is kind of like how do we bring people into Bittensor?
And so I kind of want to just like like we'll we'll move into community and QA, but as we're getting ready to talk about like next up, we should keep that theme in mind because I think that's a really important part of of what we do next. So maybe Omar, navigate us through sentiment and then we'll get into that.
Omar [42:24]Yeah, I I mean I think, you know, not so much has changed since the last episode, but sentiment has been pretty mixed, I think, associated with you know, drop in price. And, you know, we did see a bit of an uptick for a while, and it seems like a lot of that has been eliminated. And so it's you know, understandably, I think people are are in a bit of a tough spot. I will say there has been a lot of hype for new challenges. I think if you look through the slide it's saying, you know, prioritizing AI challenges sounds interesting. Looking at
cybersecurity challenges and this cybersecurity narrative. it would be great if we can get new challenges on subnet 63. you know, I think the hope is that's really what we need to sort of expand. And, you know, while HQP is in a, you know, bit of a lull as we're, you know, as BlueQubit is developing the next milestone, this seems like a great time. So hopefully you guys are all excited. We're, you know, looking forward to seeing your votes on on the challenges, which we'll release tomorrow.
let's see. Okay. Do do we count your vote?
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [43:25]I know which one I'm gonna vote for already. As long well, y as long as nobody can see what I vote for, I'm definitely voting. I'm putting my vote to good good use.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [43:36]But yeah, yeah, I don't want to I don't want to influence everybody though. But like I like I think I know which one I want to do. yeah, okay, so but but take us through okay, so this is nice. I really appreciate the like transparency. There's a little bit more pink and or you know orange or whatever than usual. So like what are the key the the key things are just slow, people want momentum, feel stalled because yeah, the challen the blue qubit challenge is off. We haven't put out another one yet. Yeah.
Omar [43:42]Okay.
Yeah.
Yeah, there there's I think a lot of you know, things have been slow over the past, you know, six weeks. partly because sort of the challenges have been running their course. but with that it means, you know, the engine's working great. So business is as usual. So there aren't a ton of, you know, major announcements, right? You know, we're working towards real breakthroughs on the challenges. and and that has people a little shaken. I think, you know, we've also been a little more quiet on the comms. So people are thinking, you know, what's going on?
And again, the hope is to rectify a lot of this with challenges we've mentioned. The JB had a comment over on the left saying, the team has a ton of ammo in the chamber, but we're trying to be careful and calculated about how we fire it. but also, you know, hurry up, it is time. And you know, we are trying to do that. because we hear you, you know, things do need to keep moving. Bittensor's a very fast paced environment and we we don't want to fall behind. So
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [45:00]It is, it is. So like one of my favorite this is by the way, this is like hypocrite Bob says this because very often do I actually act this way. But I love that line, you know, slow is smooth and smooth is fast.
Now, in reality, like Ryan and Omar will both tell you that like I wake up every morning and I'm like guys, we're gonna go. Like, here's a new thing. Quick, let's do it. Right. But like, but yeah, actually, like when it comes to Enigma, like the shame is that like it's like it's operating, it's doing what it's supposed to do. Like we have 580 up, and people are like, right, why couldn't it have been 570? And it's like, well, innovate harder, right? Like it's like, it's just like nice and sweet.
smooth and operating and no hiccups, but like that is actually like not what the Bittensor community wants, right? They want like they want action and activity and changes and pivots and iteration and moving. And so like I think we can I think we can find the right balance to draw there.
Now, I will also say that like launching these challenges, it almost sounds kind of like small and trivial. And and to a large extent, like the initial code kind of is not that hard to do. But like launching a challenge, like deciding what it should be, deciding what its milestone is, deciding how to market it, deciding who to work with and who to partner with on it. And then you have the miners coming in and
they're new to a challenge and they're finding ways to try to exploit it. So you gotta like go through the hardening phase and then from that point on, it's like picking the next milestones based on the previous solution takes a lot of work and, you know, making sure that the miners like it's it it it's a lot. Like there's a there is a lot to launching a new challenge. And so we just don't want to put out a bunch of, you know, silly, useless things, right? I don't know. I don't know. But yeah.
but we we hear you. This is all good feedback. This is and and I appreciate you like I say, I appreciate you not just bringing like the good items.
Omar [46:57]Yeah, for sure. I think from the remaining comments we haven't covered a lot of it is just, we need to do something because I think a lot of price appreciation is centered around, new and exciting things. That's how you get attention from the rest of the Bittensor ecosystem and not just the long term holders. So, we'll see. We think that could we we hope that that'll change in the in the near term.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [47:21]If this one thing hits man Cause like also like the other the other big thing so this particular champion who is championing this project within his organization also is like
Omar [47:24]Yes, that's one thing hits.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [47:39]And this other thing with this other potential major collaborator, and this other thing with this other potential major collaborator, and it's like, yeah, but like you need the internal champion, and then you need like, you know, but like if a big company does one of these and starts talking about this on socials, it's going to do so much to validate that like this is an okay thing for big companies to do. Like, and so you know, yeah, I th I think I think there is a very real chance.
that we started partnering with a couple of small companies. Yeah, okay, so we'll put a challenge or two out without some partners. We release a big challenge with a big partner, get a lot of excitement over that. And that really just like opens the floodgates to a pipeline of other like very high profile things. Like it really wouldn't I mean it really wouldn't surprise me if 63 was really thriving. you know, if we can pull this off, you know, as like one of just the top elite subnets.
and that actually brings me up to we should jump into it because we're running a little bit low on time. Next steps. Okay, so I just totally blew it and put up a thing. but at the Exploit Summit, in Const's keynote, he was talking about gamma. which by the way, we didn't really talk about today much, but we should have. We'll have to talk about that soon. We'll have to put out some some notes on that soon. But
But Const had had talked about gamma and everybody gravitated towards gamma. He also said an ominous thing that nobody is really talking about. you should go back and rewind it to right before he talked about gamma. and what he was saying, he said something. I'm gonna quote him wrong, or like I'm gonna say what I heard, which is different probably than what he said. So go back and listen to it yourself. But he he sort of provided some hints around like what the next iteration of the incentive mechanism was gonna look like.
And he suggested that it would be more involved with bringing bringing people or bringing new TAO into Bittensor as opposed to like bringing TAO to your subnet or bringing attention from Bittensor people into your subnet. Like it sounded very much like the next iteration of the incentive mechanism was going to be about bringing outside capital in and outside innovators in. And then he announced gamma.
Right, sort of and at that time we didn't really know what that was gonna look like. We know a lot more about that now. and gamma, what is gamma? Well, it's essentially a way of like measuring how dollars are spent on subnet services, right? So it's kind of like very aligned with this idea that like outside money coming and consuming subnet services. And so one of the reasons we haven't started doing the buybacks that we were planning was like we want to see what that is because if you you know, if we basically buy like buy and burn.
And then all of a sudden the next incentive mechanism is like, you know, purchase through gamma, you know, moving average of gamma coming in or something like that, then you know, we would have like blew all our powder before the incentive mechanism changed. But aligning with that concept and also like taking all the learnings that we've had putting on these qBitTensor Labs live, we are gonna try something new, which is I am going to give up my BeyondNISQ brand and we're gonna use it for a podcast.
I'll probably switch down to like NISQ or something like that. But BeyondNISQ is gonna be a podcast that's focused on the future of compute. What this is, and yeah, Omar, I appreciate you putting the QR code on there. So that's gonna bring you to like the YouTube placeholder where this stuff's gonna go. in early December, we're gonna start launching episodes of this. We're gonna take a lot of the time that we invest in preparing material for qBitTensor Labs live.
Which has a target audience of Bittensor. And we're gonna start putting a lot of that energy into a podcast that aims to go much bigger. And so instead of talking to a few hundred people who are already in Bittensor about the cool shit that we're doing with the subnets, the cool stuff that we're doing in quantum, the cool stuff that BitTensor's doing, the cool stuff that's happening in AI, we're gonna try to talk to a much bigger audience about that.
To create a lot more eyeballs that we have constant recurring touch points on. So we have more and more opportunities to bring those people in, to bring outside innovators in, to bring outside dollars in. is it gonna work? I don't know. Like I hope so. Like I feel there's a really good vibe that we have and we've got some cool ideas for how the format of this is gonna work. So yeah, we'll see, we'll see where that goes. Now, that does mean it is gonna come at the cost of like qBitTensor Labs live. Like we
it i people might not believe it, but we actually put quite a bit of energy into these updates when we do them. and so we'll sort of probably like find a different mechanism for doing like really Bittensor specific updates that's a little bit more like time efficient, and focused and maybe provides a little bit more access to the community to us through like live Q&A's and stuff like that. but then we'll we'll we'll take sort of a lot that prep time that we're putting into producing these things.
into a slightly more polished, though slightly scrappy, podcast. And yeah, the same the things to expect. you know, the three of us will be there. we do plan to do like regular interviews. So we got some really good feedback on the Taylor Hartley bring in. So we'll plan to do more things like that where we have like people come in for a segment. we also will try to sort of get some
recurring guests who are a little bit more on the regular but not on the core team. we are planning on expanding out beyond just our subnets and beyond just quantum. And so like we're framing this thing up as like the future of compute, which quantum obviously plays a huge role in. Also, like Ryan, I know, you know, ShorShot is a huge believer in like, you know, data centers in space. He's a huge you know, advocate for full self-driving and, you know, a lot of a lot of the like
you know, megafab work that's being done.
Ryan (ShorShot) [53:39]I love technology and I love like advancing technology like beyond you know beyond what we have and yeah.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [53:49]And and they and the the cool thing is that like if you look at the landscape of quantum podcasts, like and this is not not throwing any shade or anything like that, but they're all very like professional, you know, like like they're they're professional, like some of them come from a science angle, some of them come more from like an interview, like a professional interview angle.
But like there are very few things in quantum. In fact, I don't think there's anything in quantum where it's just like calling it like it is and people saying the things that are like the very loud secrets that like people aren't willing to say on podcasts. Right. And so I think it creates like a really cool opportunity for us to get in there and actually like grab a lot of them also.
Ryan (ShorShot) [54:29]think it's I I think it's the same in certain like like realms of like technology and investment type of podcast as well. It's like I'm watching this these guys talk about technology and it's like so dry. It's it just needs some like in informality to it and like you know being able to to vibe and just you know really riff with each other.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [54:42]Mm-hmm.
Totally. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so super excited about this. We're, you know, we'll see kind of where it goes. Again, what can you guys do to help? Well, you are a huge part of our audience. Like we would hope all of you guys would be, you know, would be subscribers. So I don't I mean, I assume you can scan that QR code. I haven't tried. if you can, then it brings you to the YouTube space for it.
Subscribe. We haven't pu published anything there. We probably will drop a little teaser before we start posting episodes the first or second week of December. but yes, go go ahead and subscribe so you don't miss anything. we'll also obviously post when episodes are up on Twitter and stuff like that. and then yeah, if if you know if you guys help us by subscribing so that we start to get a little bit of inertia there, we will also use all of our other platforms to bring it to all of the quantum people, all of the AI people.
and we'll love to really just create a new way to amplify Bittensor and our subnets outside of the ecosystem and also to bring more and more quantum voice. That's it. Okay, cool. We are perfect on time. I can't believe we came in on time. Did I miss anything? Did I gloss over anything? Are we good? Last chance.
Omar [56:11]Think we're good.
Bob Wold (BeyondNISQ) [56:13]Alright, well then in that case I'm gonna do the one thing I always do, which is thank all of you guys. Yeah, I know 63 saw that uptick and that correct correction back to where it was. I know that it's still sort of been like in a hard spot ever since we got kind of like arbosed a little bit. but yeah, but but but I'm thinking that we are in a pretty good spot. We've s sort of like found what our actual like baseline is and so from here.
Let's just start growing and doing good stuff and and we'll see how goes. All right. Thank you everybody. We'll talk again soon.